Caylee/Casey Anthony Case: Will Judge Rulings Today Be Defense Doomsday?
Chief Judge Belvin Perry promised to rule on 2 outstanding motions by her defense team today.
Update #1 4:45PM.. Motion to exclude trunk stain… D E N I E D
Rulings on Critical Motions regarding a hair with a "deathband" that could only belong to a deceased individual and either Casey or Caylee Anthony, and the air samples tested by Dr. Arpad Vass and found to contain chloroform levels he has never seen, in his 22 year career.
The air samples themselves are not in contention as the "hardware" and methodology in their extraction are used widely in the scientific community, and the defense team, through a stipulation agreement to withdraw contempt proceedings against him, could not argue about anything else. The defense argument was largely about the interpretation of the data that was yielded from the samples as they relate to a decompositional event in the trunk of Casey's car.
Both motions were a combination of a Frye/exclusion attempt by the defense that took several days in court to conclude, in which many observers felt were disorganized and poorly argued in contrast to the deft responses by the prosecution.
Yesterday, for the second time, Jose Baez on behalf of Casey Anthony filed a response to the State's motion to let his already withdrawn "experts" Dr. Danzinger and Dr. Weis be permitted to testify as to what Casey told them during their interviews with her.
You may recall, during the State's deposition attempt of Dr. Danzinger, Judge Perry put the kibosh to it after receiving a call from Jose Baez, and both depositions have since been sealed. Judge Perry referenced testimony about Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, or PTSD, but legal experts agree that in itself would not be grounds for suspending a deposition and immediately sealing it.
It is this editors opinion that during the deposition, Dr. Danzinger recounted parts of his interview with Casey Anthony that may have been incriminating to her.
It was abundantly clear that the defense strategy is/was to attempt to have these witnesses speak about parts of their interviews with Casey Anthony as a way to repeat her "defense" without ever taking the stand, subjecting her to cross-examination by the state.
It is also abundantly clear that Jose Baez et al did not understand the Judge's comments about these depositions the first time around.
The only way these "Docs" will be permitted to testify to anything Casey Anthony told them, is if Jose Baez presents an exception argument to the hearsay rule, and since the "declarant" or Casey Anthony, will never take the stand, 'not gonna happen.
Yesterday afternoon, the defense depositions of Tony Lazzarro and Amy Huizenga were filed with the court.
While there was largely previously known information contained in both depositions, there was one noteworthy tidbit in Ms. Huizenga's which the defense glossed over in a hurry.
Reported exclusively by www.blinkoncrime.com, the Anthony's withheld a major plumbing emergency at their home that sent someone from Hopespring Drive in a panic to locate Caylee.
For the first time, it is confirmed that Casey knew about it, and told Amy it was one of the reasons they could not move in:
Casey Told Amy About A Pipe
This article will be updated when Judge Perry rules this afternoon.
Check back to www.blinkoncrime.com for continued breaking news in the case against Casey Anthony.
Related Posts
Related Posts:
590 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
I guess I should have said asking for and being granted a retrial due to incompetent representation….
Blink, I noticed something, and maybe you can get your hands on a copy of this (since you are an ‘insider’ and all
.
But then I noticed your comment to Sammy, ie: ‘the state… not the only one…’
Yes! The defense withdrew Dr. D and Dr. W on April 18th, and within two days, the lawyers for Zenaida Gonzalez filed their own ‘EXPERT WITNESS’ witness list with the OC clerk’s office.
No coinkidink there, eh?!?!
My bet, certainly it’s Dr. Danzieger, and probably Dr. Weitz just for good measure while they’re at it, and to cover all the PTSD bases.
I think right now, a priority for Morgan, would be to depose Dr. Danzieger, even if this stayed under seal until the capital case is over, Danzieger said something during the depo with the state that would be a problem for Casey.
Thanks for the updates everyone.
Judge Perry has ruled that the jury can see and hear the evidence and decide for themselves if it is indicative of Casey’s guilt or innocence or even if it is worthy of contemplation at all…
I dont know if the Defense and Casey could hear the faint sound of Taps being played, as they lay their heads down to rest last night…but I wonder if they awoke to the sound of bells and thought: “Ask not for whom the bell tolls… it tolls for thee”
pS Wow about the Docs- I guess we know why Casey and team seemed so downtrodden after emerging from the in camera session in chambers.
Be careful of opening doors….someone else may choose to walk right in, sit right down and make themselves at home.
Archie- Hi, I understand your frustration of wanting to separate the facts from the mere speculation. I agree it is needed.
But FYI, Val also does her fair share of speculating, rather brilliantly too. She has lent her thoughts and feelings, based on known facts, ect, toward brilliant speculation that may prove out to be true. ( Im sure you have read her early thoughts on Zanny, her thoughts on the Zanny/Dora Myspace, her thoughts on Caylee IRT, premature synostosis…her thoughts on Caseys Diary…ect ect)
Val nor Blink, nor any of us, know the whole truth- we all speculate- we all post our opinions- They, Val and Blink, read the docs, they do their research, they interview people ect,they add in their thoughts,and feelings- some based on facts/ based on their hypotheses, and their own interpretations ect. They do it brilliantly, and with the hopes of helping Caylee.
So I am not sure what the problem is Archie, surely you understand that everything that has been written (here and elsewhere)in relation to this case, is not only “fact” but speculation based on facts and some just humorous others just rants ect…
My Momma always told me:
‘You must not take everything to be true that is told to you.’
Question everything- question what you hear, what you read, and what you see. To do anything less would surely lead to disaster.
Peace
AJMO
You are simply brilliant. And kind
Thank you Mom 3.0
B
TandT says:
April 27, 2011 at 10:36 am
Unreal. I have been brewing over that very thought for the past few days. No one in Caylee’s family has been there to support her. Never once sitting on ‘her side’ of the court room. Every tear shed is for poor Casey because only b/c her lies caught up with her.
No excuse or reason in the world can justify their betrayal of Caylee. N O T H I N G.
…should read….Every tear shed is for poor Casey only b/c her lies caught up with her.
Kinda loses it’s meaning if ya can translate the typos!
Happy Day, Happy Day, the Judge ruled, Dr. Voss chloroform is in….
Blink, Per your comment, which I will post here:START OF SNIP~ Yes, imo, the alleged abuse to Casey by George will be brought up at trial, specifically, because Casey is going to accuse George directly of either responsibility of what happened to Caylee as an accident, and they covered it up together, or outright murder.
This is going to happen. George will take the stand and plead the 5th, and the state will get permission to use his prior depositions and taped interviews to speak to his inferred impeachment…..END OF SNIP..My question is: How exactly is KC going to (in your words) accuse George directly? Is she going to stand up in court and make this accusation? Also in your same comment you said: START OF SNIP…..it is my strong belief that had “Casey” not been paid the fat sum from abc, and trust me when I tell you, there is more information about that we do not know than what we do at the moment, this case would have settled years ago. END OF SNIP………..My question, what more information? You don’t just settle a murder investigation out of court. This is not a lawsuit. Please explain yourself and why “we” should trust you when you state something(s)so absurd.
archie- If you have been following my work as you say, then you know I have addressed these issues at length.
Lastly, you cannot quote me without a link, it is a copyright infringement.
Thank you.
B
hiya momof3
good to see you as always
hi tarheel
hiya blink!! justice is coming for caylee!!
Did you cast your vote for Yuri yet today?
http://www.amw.com/allstar/2011/
annals
Thanks for the reminder and link to vote for Yuri. He is still in the top three. Wish there was a way know the actual vote count.
Mom3.0
Your quote from your wise mama is so true. We should all abide by that daily.
Chelsea
I almost missed your post about your new grandbaby. Congratulations, I know she will be properly loved.
So, there you have it then, Archie!
(49,) TandT, Excellent!
Blink, Your comments are upthread and I quite frankly believe you are delusional. Copyright infingement? They are your own posts on this board, I snipped your exact posts. So where are your explanations, as to your inside info and facts to back them up?
lol. “I SNIPPED your exact posts”.. No, you snipped excerpts which REQUIRE a link source. So yes, it is an infringement and just poor posting on your part.
This is not a “board” it is a news site, with significantly original content and coverage of this case.
This case is in the prosecutorial stage, and if you have been following it as closely as you say, you have your answers.
If you do not feel you do, by all means, feel free to think of me as a charlatan.
I am ok to let my work stand on it’s own.
B
lol wow Blink,
Looks like someone is putting YOU on the stand.. hehe
It is obviouos who this person might be. I can even pick that one out.
It is great puncuation also. hmmmm
anyway I am kind of confused on these two doctors and what they can do for the defense, can anyone enlighten me?
I am fighting that aftermath of lots of rain ( southwest Missouri)and leaks and such but trying to keep up as hopefully I won’t be lost when this is being discussed…
Blink are you still thinking Plea?
and Kleat, how does the state keep certain depositions and other evidence from us? still, there is quite a bit that has not been released? I am confused a little on Florida laws.
sorry I meant the state as far as what the doctors can do for them?
ATG – really appreciate your good wishes. Brings home even more how loved our babies are thus the dreadful death by her mother’s own hand of little Caylee seems even more poignant.
There has been mention of an appointment for Casey to get a second tattoo. Has there been any info as to what the tattoo was to be? If it was to be an intricate or very specilized one, Casey and the artist may have discussed it.
Also, I found it interesting that Tony stated in his depo that Casey did a great job of ‘keeping house’ on a budget. Surprise! She had tons of her mom’s money to work with.
Archie, where’s the love? No need to be angry here, we’re all friends.
Please honour our code of respect and courtesy @ BOC. This is one site that will not buy into ‘your stuff’. If your intense need to bully and harrass is any indication of your offline life, I suggest you find ways to heal thyself.
I have you in my prayers, friend.
morning everyone – great rulings so far, one more to go? sorry multi tasking, i have a 4yr. to entertain! last week i thought court was scheduled on Fri.=Good Fri. ooops, well i will ask again… is there a status hearing tomorrow and if so does anyone know the time please?Thanks in advance!!!! I Love Dr. Vass!!!!
Blink- So glad Archie brought up the “snip” of your comment about Casey blaming George. Even if it weren’t for good reason on his/her part I can use it as so. I finally gathered up enough strength to watch the 48 hours episode…….it was actually not as bad as I expected.
During the video Jose Baez once again mentions the reason Casey didn’t report Caylee missing is compelling and it will come out in court- I have a feeling this is the “Insert George Here” moment for the defense. I just feel as though the only way to make the “31 days” acceptable is to say George did this and Casey was running from him.
Any thoughts on this?
Fiona says:
Chelsea – Thank you for your kind and welcoming words, posted the other day.
Grandchildren are another kind of love we get to experience. I have a granddaughter too, like my sons she had my heart from the word go.
I agree with you, looking at one’s own grandchild and to try to comprehend what happened to precious Caylee.
Hi guys.
No problem & Thanks Blink… the word of the Day yesterday was “Brilliant” He He
Archie Hey, all this negativity is really bringing me down.
What is it you are so POed about? Is it the fact that Blink wont say why she believes what she believes? Is it because she has theories that differ from what you believe? Is it because you feel out of the loop? Is it because you believe she said that she was an “insider”-What?
Blink doesnt answer every question asked of her—dont take it personally.
Just ask anyone of us who have been around here for eons…Some days she is a talker other days not so much…Blink likes for us to try to answer the questions for ourselves…either through looking back at past articles ect or when possible, another poster will jump in and help find an answer.
The truth is that if you are looking for a statement from Blink claiming to be an “insider” you wont find one. She has never claimed that.
If you are asking Blink to back up her theories as fact…that is just asinine…as we will all have to wait for the trial to find out if any ones theory is proven. But I will tell you that many of Blinks previous theories or predictions have panned out and have been proven to be right on.
Even so, she has never claimed that they have come from any status as an “insider” I think she bases most on her astute ability to see through the BS and read people…that & her intuition and intelligence ect. JMO-
But keep in mind she is not all seeing all knowing she has been wrong before…
BTW- Blink, FYI may not be an insider, but in instances where she has interviewed/talked with “players” in this case, she has never betrayed a confidence and she never will.
She may not care if you think she is a charlatan but I do- and I can assure you she is not.
Archie, I can tell you are passionate about this case. We all are. Blinks style differs somewhat from Vals but they have agreed far more than they have disagreed. If you feel more comfortable at the HM thats okay. If you decide to stick around here thats great, or if you dont thats okay too.
What should matter most is justice for the victims, and both Blink and val are all about that, not all of this BS behind the scenes posturing,you know?
Peace AJMO
Thank you my dearest Mom 3.0-
When this case is over, I have committed to sharing a lot of things I cannot discuss prior to that time. That will not include betraying a source without their permission, but this case is very personal to me, and I think that inspiring advocacy in others is one of my objectives.
As far as archie is concerned, I have had my share of haters as you would be surprised how many people would rather see someone fail; I know I was. I simply do not have the time or inclination to make that my problem, so I don’t, lol.
B
So…….. I watched part of the interview on “In Session” this morning with Baez. Did ya’ll know he dropped out of school in the 9th grade and became a parent at the age of 17. After receiving his GED he went on to college without a clue as to what he wanted to do with his life. His then girlfriend convinced him to become a lawyer and decided to give it a try. lolol Seems as though he is STILL “trying”.
I also found out this morning that Cindy and George have moved out of their residence and are renting a home in a nearby subdivision.
Just a couple interesting tidbits…..
are opening statements supposed to start on the 16th? this may sound, well, crazy, but i took the 16th and 17th off of work to watch them. any response is appreciated!
Chloroform evidence allowed at trial. Evidence now places Caylee’s body inside the trunk of the car.
Search on the internet shows “Neck breaking” and “How to make Chloroform” excuses away an “accident” as the defense will try to claim.
I wonder if it will come out in the trial that George was chasing Casey in his car, and she lost him. I wonder why he was chasing her. did he know Caylee was already dead? This was early on.
Archie I dont post here anymore because I got that not so friendly feeling from,well I cant really remember now,but I must tell you Blink is a ,passionate,articulate,classy gal,who writes brilliant Im offended by that #15 post.When I think of the familys shes helped and she always keeps it respectful and truthful and I will say it again CLASSY.
R. L.
Thank you kindly, and I hope you return to comfortable. You are very welcome here.
B
@ Dave S.~
That incident happened long before Caylee was missing. George was confused about the dates. When that happened Caylee was home with Cindy…
Sorry, hit submit before I was finished!
Casey was supposedly driving Cindy’s SUV when that happened. I believe they were able to figure out the timeline with that based on the EZ pass records…
Nikki — it will depend if they can seat a jury in one week as to whether openings will begin as scheduled.
Archie
If you think that you disagree with something on this site, we state it in a respectful manner. We DO NOT attack one another.
There is absolutely zero reason for uglyness.
For those interested in Judge Perry this long article in Orlando Magazine is very illuminating.
http://www.orlandomagazine.com/Orlando-Magazine/April-2011/Order-in-His-Court/
Given his schedule, I wondered whether he’s married (answer; yes) and went looking for a profile, thus discovering this good read.
Vote for Yuri Melich as America’s Most Wanted 2011 All-Star today.
http://www.amw.com/allstar/2011/
22 NoseyRosey – I totally agree with you on that scenario. I will be so angry when Baez comes out explaining how Casey was running from her Mother because she couldn’t bring herself to explain how George accidently allowed Caylee to drowned in the pool (the ladder). She couldn’t hurt her mother like that. Casey moved Caylee to protect George. She did this out of love.
25 Classygal – I wondered how long George and Cindy could live in that home. Too many terrible things happened there.
When the dust settles Casey can not say that her lawyers did not try their darnest, through repetitive motioning, to get key evidence tossed.
It appears that the good judge has been doing his homework, his rejection of said motions are well written and backed by solid case law…therefore his rejection of the motion against his rejection is so sweet, clear and to the point. IE tossing the tell tale stain in the trunk.
Peace and hugs to all….Miss Karma has arrived on the scene in Orlando and Sweet Lady Justice is waiting to be called. Patience is the word of the day, faith in the goodwill and judgment of the 12 Florida citizens who will take on this task is needed. Prayers to the those 12, once picked, they will undertake an arduous task..Caylee’s justice.
blink
your a class act! you handle these people with class and finesse lol I would have give them a piece of my mind whats left of it! but no you take snark and reply with class
hugs my friend!! may I lern from you!!
inudder wurds I can be onerie
“Karma Planning Spontaneous Trip to Orlando”
(snip)
” … While it’s somewhat unclear exactly where Karma has been this whole time- some say gagged and chained next to the smashed crosses in the blackhole that is Cindy Anthony’s soul- while others think Jose Baez may have tried paying her off to stay out of town- one thing is certain: the entire defense team is now sporting a classic deer-in-the-headlights “Oh. Shit.” kinda look.” (snip)
Entire read @ … (thanks eggtree!)
http://eggtreenews.wordpress.com/
Classyhgal- Hi I did not watch the whole interview but did catch where Baez mentioned Cindy being one of the reasons this case has gotten the kind of attention it has…I have been thinking- I think we are gonna be hearing alot more about the CMA club and how it was a ” cult”… and how its all Cindys fault… But before it comes to that- I just want to be on record calling BS- Casey was a big girl and could have at any point walked away from her mom and her dad…leaving them all in the dust…but that would have meant no free ride.
Blink I await the time when you can speak about things more freely. I know you must have alot to say, and I know how much of yourself is wrapped up in Caylees case.
I can only imagine how hard it must be to keep everything under your hat, including your feelings.
Just wanted to let you know I will be here when the time comes for you to be more outspoken.
PS- You were right again- all of the defenses motions have been denied…waiting on Dr. Vass’s decomp. air test analysis.
Status hearing/motions hearing on Monday.
Peace MOO
Thank you friend
B
Oh just want to say to Nikki- those are the dates that the trial is slated to start..but who can say for certain…with jury selection ectt. I will keep my fingers crossed for you, that youll be able to catch it…if not enjoy your time off- and catch it later on the web.
In response to Archie (Post #15):
Dude or Dudette – you need to chill. You’re in a friendly place, Blink is excellent in her field. If she states something as fact you can count on it. Otherwise, learn and join in the discussion – it’s okay if everyone doesn’t share the same opinion. When you are in someone elses home, please be respectful.
In my humble opinion.
I believe…Justice for Caylee.
Valley Girl, Thanks for clearing that up.
I was trying to see if that was maybe tied into the “plumbing problem”.
Sorry off topic; am watching our Royal Wedding, so joyful and happy. Wonderful seeing families enjoying themselves from young to old. You are never far from my thoughts though Caylee – Justice is coming.
Judge Perry was in Palm Beach County yesterday looking at the jury selection quarters. Maybe that is where they are going to start…
The Fight Between Cindy & Casey on the Night of June 15, 2008;
has always been a matter of heresay(?); the Grunds told LE that Lee told Jesse about it. I’ve read rumors that the fight was also reported by “a neighbor” & Mark Fuhrman to LE, but I never saw it in any LE report or deposition.
I was reminded about it browsing rusty b shackleford’s timeline calander over at the Hinky Meter. On his entry for August 6, 2008 is;
“Mark Fuhrman advises OCSO that Cindy told him that she and Casey had big fight on 6/15. She had withheld this information form OCSO”
http://www.thehinkymeter.com/Library/CMA/cmacalendar.pdf
My question; has anyone seen any LE report or deposition of Mark Fuhrman? Or any official document of report(s) of the 6/15 Fight other than the Grunds?
I saw that in my local paper and I live in WPB I wish I were called to be on the jury
Chelsea
I thought about you as Kate and William came out on the balcony for the public appearance and kiss. Kate is a beautiful young woman. Just looking at the TV images and the sparkle in Kate’s eyes gives me hope that she will contribute much to the quality of the Royal family.
Did you catch the fly-over? An old Wellington four-engined bomber from WWII escorted by what appeared to be two spitfires. Brought back a lot of memories for me.
Blink – apologies for using this site for off topic comments but I would just like to say to ATG – The fly past was my hubbies favourite bit of the day, he is a World War 11 buff. Even met and dined with Bob Morgan of Memphis Belle fame! But guess what, the minute I had watched the happy couple on the balcony, I was logging in to this site to check out any news as I am desperate to hear that JBP allowed Dr Vass evidence in.